Quick Search   
 

Suffolk County's 100 Top Restaurants

Wondering where other people on Long Island are looking to eat?  These are the Suffolk County restaurants that are viewed most often. Don't see your favorite restaurant here?  Then cast your vote for it to the right. This page is updated weekly.

Click here to view Nassau County's Top 100
 

Vote for your favorite Suffolk County restaurant!

There are currently 1336 Suffolk County restaurants listed on Eat Out Long Island!
Click here to search for restaurants in Nassau and Suffolk County.
Restaurant Name Cuisine Address City Phone Website  
1.

Ciao Baby Review

Italian

204 Jericho Turnpike (Mayfair Shopping Center)

Commack

 (631) 543-1400 Yes Rate It
2.

56th Fighter Group Review

American

Republic Airport (Gate 1 - Route 110)

Farmingdale

 (631) 694-8280 Yes Rate It
3.

H2O Seafood Grill Review

Seafood / Sushi

215 West Main Street

Smithtown

 (631) 361-6464 Yes Rate It
4.

Riverview

Seafood

3 Consuelo Place

Oakdale

 (631) 589-2694 Yes Rate It
5.

Sweetwater's Review

Seafood / Steak / Pasta

470 Wheeler Road (Route 111)

Hauppauge

 (631) 348-0808 Yes Rate It
6.

Library Cafe Review

American / Burgers

274 Main Street

Farmingdale

 (516) 752-7678 Yes Rate It
7.

Argyle Grill and Tavern Review

American / Seafood

90 Deer Park Avenue

Babylon

 (631) 321-4900 Yes Rate It
8.

Pace's Steak House Review

Steakhouse / American

325 Nesconset Highway (Route 347)

Hauppauge

 (631) 979-7676 Yes Rate It
9.

Honu Kitchen

New American

363 New York Avenue

Huntington

 (631) 421-6900 Yes Rate It
10.

Kotobuki Review

Japanese / Sushi

86 Deer Park Avenue

Babylon

 (631) 321-8387 No Rate It
11.

Cirella's Review

Italian

14 Broadhollow Road (Route 110)

Melville

 (631) 385-7380 No Rate It
12.

Kotobuki Review

Japanese / Sushi

377 Nesconset Highway

Hauppauge

 (631) 360-3969 No Rate It
13.

Harbor Crab Company Review

Seafood

116 Division Street

Patchogue

 (631) 687-2722 Yes Rate It
14.

Casa Rustica Review

Italian

175 West Main Street

Smithtown

 (631) 265-9265 Yes Rate It
15.

Captain Bill's Review

Seafood

122 Ocean Avenue

Bay Shore

 (631) 665-6262 Yes Rate It
16.

Bonwit Inn

Continental

1 Vanderbilt Parkway

Commack

 (631) 499-2068 Yes Rate It
17.

Sempre Vivolo Review

Italian

696 Motor Parkway

Hauppauge

 (631) 435-1737 No Rate It
18.

Pace's Steak House Review

Steakhouse / American

318 Wynn Lane

Port Jefferson

 (631) 331-9200 Yes Rate It
19.

Butterfield's Review

New American

661 Old Willets Path

Hauppauge

 (631) 851-1507 Yes Rate It
20.

Passion Fish

American / Seafood

379 Dune Road

Westhampton Beach

 (631) 288-5250 No Rate It
21.

Tellers Chophouse Review

Steakhouse / American

605 Main Street

Islip

 (631) 277-7070 Yes Rate It
22.

La Bella Palermo Review

Italian

90 West Main Street (Babylon Commons)

Babylon

 (631) 321-0763 No Rate It
23.

The Cooperage Inn Review

American / Steak / Seafood

2218 Sound Avenue

Baiting Hollow

 (631) 727-8994 Yes Rate It
24.

Milk and Sugar Cafe Review

American / Coffee / Breakfast

49 West Main Street

Bay Shore

 (631) 969-3655 Yes Rate It
25.

Peter's Italian Review

Italian

132 West Main Street

Babylon

 (631) 422-9233 No Rate It
26.

21 Main Review

Steakhouse / Continental

21 Montauk Highway

West Sayville

 (631) 567-0900 Yes Rate It
27.

Fat Fish

Seafood / American

28 Cottage Avenue

Bay Shore

 (631) 666-2899 Yes Rate It
28.

Snapper Inn Review

Seafood

500 Shore Drive

Oakdale

 (631) 589-0248 Yes Rate It
29.

Blackstone Steakhouse

Steakhouse / Sushi / American

10 Pinelawn Road

Melville

 (631) 271-7780 Yes Rate It
30.

105 Harbor Review

Steak / Seafood / Raw Bar

105 Harbor Road (Route 25A)

Cold Spring Harbor

 (631) 367-3166 Yes Rate It
31.

25 East American Bistro

Eclectic

25 East Broadway (Route 25A - Danfords Inn)

Port Jefferson

 (631) 928-5200 Yes Rate It
32.

Garden Grill Review

American

64 North Country Road

Smithtown

 (631) 265-8771 Yes Rate It
33.

Ristorante Gemelli

Italian

175 East Main Street

Babylon

 (631) 321-6392 Yes Rate It
34.

Papa Joe's Shrimp and Crab Factory

Seafood

111 West Broadway

Port Jefferson

 (631) 473-5656 No Rate It
35.

Off the Wall Review

Eclectic

65 Wall Street

Huntington

 (631) 385-9255 No Rate It
36.

Cricket's Review

American

98 Main Street

Sayville

 (631) 567-6345 No Rate It
37.

Bayport House

New American

291 Bayport Avenue

Bayport

 (631) 472-2444 No Rate It
38.

Louis XVI Review

New French

600 South Ocean Avenue

Patchogue

 (631) 654-8970 Yes Rate It
39.

Tutto Pazzo

Italian / Clam Bar

84 New York Avenue

Huntington

 (631) 271-2253 Yes Rate It
40.

Beachtree Cafe Review

Burgers / Pub

166 West Main Street

East Islip

 (631) 277-4800 Yes Rate It
41.

Brennan's

Continental / American

546 Route 111

Hauppauge

 (631) 979-7855 No Rate It
42.

Cafe Joelle on Main Street Review

American / Eclectic / Burgers

25 Main Street

Sayville

 (631) 589-4600 Yes Rate It
43.

The Harborside Review

Seafood

503 East Main Street

Patchogue

 (631) 654-9290 No Rate It
44.

Bella Vita City Grill Review

Italian / American

430-16 North Country Road

Saint James

 (631) 862-8060 Yes Rate It
45.

Elk Street Grille Review

New American

201 Main Street

Port Jefferson

 (631) 331-0960 Yes Rate It
46.

The Martha Jefferson

Seafood / Italian / American

Port Jefferson Harbor

Port Jefferson

 (631) 331-3333 Yes Rate It
47.

Pasta Pasta

Italian

234 East Main Street

Port Jefferson

 (631) 331-5335 Yes Rate It
48.

Country House Review

American

Main Street

Stony Brook

 (631) 751-3332 Yes Rate It
49.

Nocello's Review

Northern Italian

843 Fort Salonga Road (Route 25A)

Northport

 (631) 262-8565 Yes Rate It
50.

Black Forest Brew Haus Review

German / American

2015 New Highway

Farmingdale

 (631) 391-9500 Yes Rate It
51.

Baja Grill Review

Mexican

20 East Main Street

Smithtown

 (631) 979-2252 No Rate It
52.

Vintage Prime Steakhouse Review

Steakhouse / Seafood / American

433 North Country Road

Saint James

 (631) 862-6440 No Rate It
53.

Harvest on Fort Pond

Northern Italian / Mediterranean

11 South Emery Street

Montauk

 (631) 668-5574 Yes Rate It
54.

Three Village Inn

American

150 Main Street

Stony Brook

 (631) 751-0555 Yes Rate It
55.

Watercolors

American

598 Broad Hollow Road (Huntington Hilton)

Melville

 (631) 845-1000 Yes Rate It
56.

Collins and Main

New American

100 South Main Street

Sayville

 (631) 563-0805 Yes Rate It
57.

Jonathan's Ristorante Review

Italian

15 Wall Street

Huntington

 (631) 549-0055 Yes Rate It
58.

Blackbird's Grille

Southern / American / Cajun / Burgers

553 Old Montauk Highway

Sayville

 (631) 563-4144 Yes Rate It
59.

Mazzi Review

Continental

493 East Jericho Turnpike (Route 25)

Huntington Station

 (631) 421-3390 No Rate It
60.

34 New Street

New American

34 New Street

Huntington

 (631) 427-3434 Yes Rate It
61.

Vittorio's Review

Italian

184 Broadway

Amityville

 (631) 264-3333 No Rate It
62.

Sushi Park Review

Sushi / Japanese / Buffet

6137 Jericho Turnpike

Commack

 (631) 499-1465 Yes Rate It
63.

Cafe La Strada Review

Italian

352 Wheeler Road

Hauppauge

 (631) 234-5550 No Rate It
64.

Bistro Cassis

French

55-B Wall Street

Huntington

 (631) 421-4122 Yes Rate It
65.

Piccolo Review

Italian / New American

215 Wall Street (Southdown Shopping Ctr.)

Huntington

 (631) 424-5592 No Rate It
66.

Azuma

Japanese / Sushi

252 Broadway

Greenlawn

 (631) 262-7200 Yes Rate It
67.

Besito

Mexican

402 New York Avenue

Huntington

 (631) 549-0100 Yes Rate It
68.

Meritage Review

Italian / American

14 Station Road

Bellport

 (631) 286-3300 No Rate It
69.

Sayville Inn

American Bistro

199 Middle Road

Sayville

 (631) 567-0033 No Rate It
70.

The Bellport

American

159 South Country Road

Bellport

 (631) 286-7550 No Rate It
71.

Terry G's Steak and Seafood Grill Review

American / Steakhouse / Seafood

354 Main Street

Farmingdale

 (631) 845-9300 No Rate It
72.

Brick House Brewery Review

American / Burgers

67 West Main Street

Patchogue

 (631) 447-2337 Yes Rate It
73.

Abel Conklin's

Steakhouse / Ribs

54 New Street

Huntington

 (631) 385-1919 Yes Rate It
74.

Bonbori Tiki Review

Japanese / Sushi

14 Elm Street

Huntington

 (631) 673-0400 No Rate It
75.

PG Steakhouse

Steakhouse / American

1745 East Jericho Turnpike (Route 25)

Huntington

 (631) 499-1005 Yes Rate It
76.

Panama Hatties Review

New American

872 East Jericho Turnpike (Route 25 - Post Plaza)

Huntington Station

 (631) 351-1727 Yes Rate It
77.

Antares Cafe

American

2530 Manhanset Road

Greenport

 (631) 477-8839 No Rate It
78.

O Sole Mio Review

Pizza / Italian

2194 Nesconset Highway

Stony Brook

 (631) 751-1600 Yes Rate It
79.

La Panchita Review

Mexican / Spanish

67 West Main Street

Smithtown

 (631) 360-0627 No Rate It
80.

Claudio's

Seafood / American

111 Main Street

Greenport

 (631) 477-8252 Yes Rate It
81.

La Parma

Southern Italian

452 West Jericho Turnpike

Huntington Station

 (631) 367-6360 Yes Rate It
82.

Meehan's Review

American / Irish

371 New York Avenue

Huntington

 (631) 351-0831 No Rate It
83.

Mario Review

Northern Italian / Seafood

644 Vanderbilt Motor Parkway

Hauppauge

 (631) 273-9407 Yes Rate It
84.

Barolo

Italian / Continental

1197 Walt Whitman Road (Route 110)

Melville

 (631) 421-3750 No Rate It
85.

The Steam Room Review

Seafood

4 East Broadway

Port Jefferson

 (631) 928-6690 Yes Rate It
86.

Branchinelli's Review

Italian / Pizza

555 Route 111

Hauppauge

 (631) 724-6663 No Rate It
87.

La Grange Inn Review

Continental / Steak

499 Montauk Highway

West Islip

 (631) 669-0765 Yes Rate It
88.

The Cooke's In Review

Caribbean / Soul Food / Southern

767 New York Avenue

Huntington

 (631) 424-2181 No Rate It
89.

A Touch of Venice

Italian / Seafood

2255 Wickham Avenue

Mattituck

 (631) 298-5851 Yes Rate It
90.

Legal Sea Foods

Seafood

160 Walt Whitman Road (Walt Whitman Mall)

Huntington Station

 (631) 271-9777 Yes Rate It
91.

Piccola Bussola Review

Italian

970 West Jericho Turnpike (Route 25)

Huntington

 (631) 692-6300 No Rate It
92.

The Gatsby

Continental

712 Main Street (Montauk Highway)

Islip

 (631) 581-1900 Yes Rate It
93.

Blue Water Review

New American / Caribbean

183 Main Street

Sayville

 (631) 589-4900 No Rate It
94.

Gosman's Dock Review

Seafood

500 West Lake Drive

Montauk

 (631) 668-5330 Yes Rate It
95.

Suki Zuki Review

Japanese / Sushi

688 Montauk Highway (Main Street)

Water Mill

 (631) 726-4600 No Rate It
96.

Canterbury Ales

Burgers / English

314 New York Avenue

Huntington

 (631) 549-4404 Yes Rate It
97.

Aix en-Provence

French / Seafood

134 New York Avenue

Huntington

 (631) 549-3338 Yes Rate It
98.

Alison

New American / Seafood

95 School Street

Bridgehampton

 (631) 537-7100 Yes Rate It
99.

Red Bar and Restaurant

New American

417 New York Avenue

Huntington

 (631) 673-0304 Yes Rate It
100.

Fabio's

Brazilian

56 Stewart Avenue

Huntington

 (631) 549-3900 No Rate It


Join Our Email List | Contact Us | About Us | Add a Listing for Free | Restaurant Owners | Disclaimer

Eat Out Long Island is a comprehensive source for everything edible on Long Island. Our constantly growing directory of restaurants spans from the western border of Nassau County to the tips of the North and South forks.  Plus, our extensive Restaurant Finder makes it easy to track down the perfect place to eat no matter where you are in Nassau and Suffolk Counties.