Restaurant Review - Oconee East Diner - Islip - Eat Out Long Island
Restaurant Review:
Oconee East Diner in Islip
Submitted by: John Mcnally on Thursday, September 15, 2016
Ratings listed from 1 (lowest - poor) to 10 (highest - excellent) Return to the review index page


The food was awesome. I had the prime rib. It melted in your mouth. I have 4 children and when we come here they give so much food we eat leftovers for 2 days. Great food, large portions.


We come often and my kids love to see the decorations that the owners put up. It's really a great diner. It's clean, it's relaxing, they don't rush you out, the wait staff is great and the owner stops by the table to see if everything is to your liking. He loves the kids and always has a smile.


All of the staff is exceptional. The bus boys, the waiters, the host...excellent.


The experience is great. My family loves this diner and I drive from Massapequa passing about a half dozen diners for this place. But make sure you're hungry when you come since the portions are gigantic. A great value for the dollar.


Great time, great food, well worth the drive. Lots of parking and lots of leftovers. Come early. It's very busy on the weekends starting about 6:00pm.
Would you return?

Join Our Email List | Contact Us | About Us | Add a Listing for Free | Disclaimer/Terms of Use
Eat Out Long Island is the source for everything edible on Long Island. Our constantly growing directory of restaurants spans from the western border of Nassau County to the tips of the North and South forks.  Plus, our extensive Restaurant Finder makes it easy to track down the perfect place to eat no matter where you are in Nassau and Suffolk Counties.